Skip to main content

Blog #2: Scouting the Territory

So far, I have decided to continue with my topic focusing on the demographics of college students in the United States and in Europe in comparison with the cost of higher education. I have thought this topic is particularly interesting from the beginning, but even more so since working on the analytical essay, where I have explored the types of students who attend college and receive financial aid in the United States. I have yet to refine this topic into a more specific idea, but I am sure that I will pursue something in this area.
My exploration began with a Google search: "college in Europe vs US." This lead me to many results, mostly blog posts from a student's point of view or from college review sites. A search for "higher education in Europe vs US" showed me many more of these blog posts, as well as a research article, which will definitely serve as a great source from academia. After a few more searches, I found that the most useful terms to use were "university," "university system," "education system," and "higher education" in combination with the US and Europe or the names of various European countries.
I found a few scholarly articles which seem important for my exploration of this topic. The one I found from my Google search is called "Higher Education: Europe vs. USA" by Dr. Andrzej J. Gapinski from Penn State University. This article explores the education system in both locations, as well as the effects that higher education have on the society and economy in each. After using some of the same terms on Google Scholar ("college in Europe vs US"), I came across a vast variety of articles on many different topics within this idea. While I did not read all of them closely enough to determine whether or not I will use any of them for sure for my final paper, I did come across a few that seem exciting and worthwhile to look at. These include: "Community College/Cluster Connections: Specialization and Competitiveness in the United States and Europe" by Stuart A. Rosenfeld and "Quality assurance in Europe and the US: Professional and political economic framing of higher education policy" by Rhoades and Sporn. Even from just a glance at these articles, I already know they will be helpful for my topic because they focus on college itself along with the effects higher education on society. A quick Amazon.com search of "college in Europe" left me with only one good result: "College Beyond the States: European Schools That Will Change Your Life Without Breaking the Bank" by Jennifer Viemont.
An interesting idea (I would even go so far to consider this a borderline controversy) in regard to this topic is whether or not free tuition in Europe will get you the same quality of education that people pay thousands upon thousands for in the United States. While I've noticed that the general consensus is that the education is of the same quality, there are just a few people who disagree.
The resources I found that I think will be most helpful are ones that I mentioned earlier on in the post. I think the most helpful will be the Gapinski article, because of how structured it is in describing the type of education and its effect on society.


Comments

  1. I read through the Gapinski article and it looks useful.

    One thing you will have to think about is what particular angle you want to take on the topic. The one you mention of students from the US possibly studying in countries where they have basically free tuition is interesting. A quick search on "americans going to college abroad" turned up several articles on places students can go to get practically free college -- including this one:
    https://studentloanhero.com/featured/6-countries-with-free-college-for-americans/
    I'd be curious to know if more students are pursuing that avenue these days, as tuition here continues to rise. And it would be a very interesting and unique project. It's amazing to think about how many international students are flooding the US because of how our increasingly privatized schools are working hard to recruit them -- and those students pay "out-of-state" and international fees that are a real boon to public colleges.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Blog #1: Topic Idea

I am thinking about writing my final paper about college in other countries as compared to the United States. During a recent visit to Austria, I learned that tuition is free or very affordable there as well in many other countries, but the attendance there is much lower as high school graduates often choose to go to trade school or enter the workforce. I thought this was very interesting, because in the United States tuition is much higher, and more often than not forces students and their families into debt for many years, but there is so much pressure for high school graduates to attend university. I would particularly like to explore the demographics of students attending universities in both settings.

Blog #9: Argument and Counterargument

Argument: My argument sets out to address why American students are willing to pay more for their education by attending colleges in America when they have the option of practically (or actually) free college tuition in Europe. Students from the United States choose to attend universities “at home” instead of in Europe because of better graduation rates and employability due to a more career-focused model of education, despite rising tuition costs that result from an increase in privatization. Counterargument: My counterargument comes from Caitlin Zaloom’s enmeshed autonomy. As we’ve seen, the higher education system in the US forces students to rely on their parents to help fund their education. Zaloom argues in favor of traditional models of European education because it puts less of a financial strain on students and their families. She also uses Germany as an example because of its free tuition. Families who send their students there are only required to support with living exp

Literature Review #3

This article provides an interesting analysis of how the idea of Europe or traveling to Europe has been transformed in American minds, and how this transformation affects students and their decision to study abroad. The author brings in multiple authors, most notably Ernest Hemingway, Mark Twain, and Henry James, whose literature is indicative of the views Americans have of Europe. Woolf paints a romantic picture of study abroad, which makes the idea of traveling to Europe to learn feel elitist and more like a vacation than a time to study. Woolf, Michael. “The Baggage They Carry: Study Abroad and the Construction of ‘Europe’ in the American Mind.” Frontiers: The Interdisciplinary Journal of Study Abroad, vol. 21, Frontiers Journal, 2011. About the Author: Michael Woolf is the Deputy President Strategic Development at CAPA, the Global Education Network and serves on the Curriculum Committee of the Forum on Education Abroad. Woolf is definitely experienced in the field of study abro